Games like Mafia: The Old Country

Ranked by shared qualities, not genre tags.

What defines Mafia: The Old Country

Crime & Underworld95%
Single-Player90%
Third-Person85%
Campaign85%
Historical80%
Gunplay75%
Gritty70%
Grim70%
Menacing65%
Handcrafted World60%
Wide-Linear60%
Melee Combat55%
Power & Corruption55%
Cover Shooter50%
Dialogue Trees40%
Stealth35%
Redemption35%
Mafia II73% match

Shares Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Historical, Gunplay.

Both lean into Crime & Underworld, Campaign, Single-Player, Third-Person.

Crime & Underworld95%Campaign90%Single-Player85%Third-Person85%

Shares Crime & Underworld, Gritty, Third-Person, Gunplay.

Both lean into Crime & Underworld, Single-Player, Gritty, Third-Person.

Crime & Underworld75%Single-Player65%Gritty85%Third-Person65%

Shares Third-Person, Historical, Crime & Underworld, Gunplay.

Both lean into Single-Player, Third-Person, Historical, Crime & Underworld.

Single-Player90%Third-Person90%Historical85%Crime & Underworld70%
Mafia60% match

Shares Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Historical, Gunplay.

Both lean into Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Campaign, Historical.

Crime & Underworld95%Third-Person85%Campaign85%Historical70%

Shares Third-Person, Crime & Underworld, Melee Combat, Grim.

Both lean into Third-Person, Campaign, Crime & Underworld, Melee Combat.

Third-Person90%Campaign85%Crime & Underworld75%Melee Combat85%

Shares Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Gunplay, Grim.

Both lean into Single-Player, Crime & Underworld, Campaign, Third-Person.

Single-Player90%Crime & Underworld85%Campaign90%Third-Person85%

Shares Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Melee Combat, Grim.

Both lean into Single-Player, Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Campaign.

Single-Player95%Crime & Underworld75%Third-Person80%Campaign80%
Manhunt49% match

Shares Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Grim, Menacing.

Both lean into Single-Player, Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Campaign.

Single-Player80%Crime & Underworld68%Third-Person75%Campaign70%

Shares Third-Person, Gunplay, Melee Combat, Grim.

Both lean into Third-Person, Gunplay, Campaign, Single-Player.

Third-Person75%Gunplay80%Campaign65%Single-Player60%

Shares Gunplay, Third-Person, Historical, Grim.

Both lean into Gunplay, Third-Person, Single-Player, Historical.

Gunplay95%Third-Person80%Single-Player70%Historical75%
Mafia III48% match

Shares Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Gunplay, Grim.

Both lean into Crime & Underworld, Third-Person, Gunplay, Campaign.

Crime & Underworld85%Third-Person80%Gunplay75%Campaign65%

Shares Third-Person, Gunplay, Menacing, Melee Combat.

Both lean into Single-Player, Third-Person, Campaign, Gunplay.

Single-Player95%Third-Person95%Campaign80%Gunplay75%